- 권한신청
- P-ISSN1229-0661
- E-ISSN1229-0661
- KCI
이익충돌 상황에서 공개가 자문행동에 주는 효과: 자문가역할수행집단과 사익추구집단의 비교
Factors affecting Disclosing conflicts of Interest on consultation: comparison with Role-oriented and Self-interest Groups
김지혜 (연세대학교 심리학과)
정경미 (연세대학교)
- 다운로드 수
- 조회수
초록
이익충돌은 경영, 의학, 연구 등 자문이 필요한 상황에서 윤리문제를 일으키는 주요인 중 하나로 파악된다. 실제 현장에서는 공개를 해결책으로 주로 사용하고 있으나, 공개의 효과에 대한 기존 연구들의 보고는 일관적이지 않다. 본 연구에서는 개인의 이익추구 성향에 따라 공개가 자문 행동에 주는 효과가 달라지는지를 실험적으로 연구하였다. 참가자는 20대에서 40대의 성인남녀 190명(남: 65명, 여: 125명)으로, 온라인으로 실험과 설문조사에 응답하였다. 실험에서 참가자는 자문가가 되어 가상의 파트너에게 정보를 제공하였다. 이때 참가자는 자문가로서의 역할을 수행하면 적은 보상을 받으나 사익을 추구하면 많은 보상을 받게 되는 이익충돌 상황에 노출되었다. 총 2개의 과제 중 첫 번째 과제를 통해 자문가 역할을 최대화하는 집단과 사익추구를 최대화하는 두 집단으로 구분하였다. 두 번째 과제에서는 이 두 집단에게 각각 이익충돌 상황에 대해 공개 여부를 자발적으로 결정하게 한 뒤 공개여부가 후속적인 자문행동에 어떠한 영향을 주는 지 탐색하였다. 연구 결과, 자문가역할수행집단과 사익추구집단 간 공개여부의 선택비율에는 차이가 없었다. 그러나, 두 집단 간 공개여부에 따라 자문행동에는 차이를 보였는데, 자문가역할수행집단에서는 자발적으로 공개를 선택한 집단이 비공개를 선택한 집단에 비해 파트너에게 정확한 정보를 제공해 주었다. 반면, 사익을 추구한 집단에서는 공개 여부가 자문행동에 영향을 주지 않았다. 이러한 결과를 바탕으로 연구의 의의와 더불어 후속 연구를 위한 제언을 논의하였다.
- keywords
- 이익충돌, 공개, 자문행동, 성인의 도덕성, 도덕적 행동, Conflicts of interest, Disclosure, Consultation, Moral behavior, Adults' Morality
Abstract
A conflict of interest (COI) places people in ethical dilemma when providing consultation in a field of business, medical/pharmaceutical industry, research etc. Disclosure is a commonly adopted strategy for the adverse effect of COI, but previous studies have reported inconsistent results. This investigated whether individual differences in pursuing self-interest influence differently on consultation behavior during voluntary- or no-disclosure of COI conditions. A total of 190 adults participated in an on-line experiment which consisted of two tasks. On the 1st task, participants were divided into either a role-oriented group or a self-interest group depending on their consultation choice on the task. On the 2nd task, participants were required to choose whether to disclose COI to his/her virtual partner and provided consultation to them. No group differences were found in frequency of choosing voluntary disclosure. For the role-oriented group, the voluntary disclosure group provided unbiased information to the virtual partners than the no disclosure group. However, no group difference between voluntary- and no-disclosure group in the self-interest group. Implications and limitations are further discussed.
- keywords
- 이익충돌, 공개, 자문행동, 성인의 도덕성, 도덕적 행동, Conflicts of interest, Disclosure, Consultation, Moral behavior, Adults' Morality
참고문헌
김영훈 (2014). 체면, 존엄 문화를 통해 살펴본 동아시아 도덕성의 기반: 동아시아 사람들은 언제 비도덕적인 행동을 할까? 한국심리학회, 한국심리학회 연차 학술발표 논문집, 2014(1), 116.
문용린, 문미희 (1993). 한국 청소년의 도덕판단력 발달 연구개관-DIT 를 사용한 연구를 중심으로-. 청소년학연구, 1(1), 43-57.
박정은, 박혜경 (2013). 사회경제적 지위와 이타성 및 도덕성의 관계. 한국심리학회, 한국심리학회 연차학술발표 논문집 2013(1), 331.
신홍임 (2015). 문화성향은 윤리적 의사결정의 과정에 영향을 주는가?. 한국심리학회지: 문화 및 사회문제, 21(1), 67-96.
윤성연, 정경미 (2014). 대학생 자녀가 지각한 부모의 과보호 양육수준과 자녀의 도덕성 간 관계. 한국심리학회지: 문화 및 사회문제, 20(4), 307-328.
이경원 (1996). 콜버그의 인지적 도덕성 발달에 관한 조사연구. 초등도덕교육, 1(0), 141- 166.
이정훈 (2008). 유교문화권에서 부모의 양육행위가 자녀 도덕성 형성에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구. 한국심리학회지: 일반, 27(3), 783-818.
정옥분, 곽경화 (2001). 성년기의 도덕성에 관한 연구: 보살핌 지향의 도덕성과 정의 지향의 도덕성을 중심으로. 대한가정학회지, 39(12), 225-238.
정옥분, 곽경화 (2003). 배려지향적 도덕성과 정의지향적 도덕성에 관한 연구: 성과 성역할 정체감 및 연령과의 관계를 중심으로. 한국아동학회지, 24(1), 1-20.
정창우 (2004). 세계화 시대의 도덕 교육에서 정의윤리와 배려윤리의 통합적 접근법 연구. 윤리연구, 56(0), 331-356.
최상진, 김기범 (2000). 체면의 심리적 구조. 한국심리학회지: 사회 및 성격, 14(1), 185-202.
국제투명성기구 (Transparency International), http://www.transparency.org
한겨레, 2015.1.1., 한겨레사회정책연구소 조사결과 발표
Ariely, D. (2012). The Honest Truth About Dishonesty, Harper Collins. 이경식 역(2013). 거짓말하는 착한 사람들. 서울: 청림출판.
Bazerman, M. H., Loewenstein, G., & Moore, D. A. (2002). Why Good accounts do bad audits, Harvard Business Review 97-101.
Bero, L. A., Glantx S., Hong, M. K. (2005). The Limits of Competing Interest Disclosures. Tobacco Control, 14, 118-126.
Cain, D. M., Loewenstein, G., & Moore, D. A. (2005). The Dirt on Coming Clean: Perverse Effects of Disclosing Conflicts of Interest. Journal of Legal Studies, 34(1), 1-24.
Cain, D. M., Loewenstein, G., & Moore, D. A. (2011). When Sunlight Fails to Disinfect: Understanding the Perverse Effects of Disclosing Conflicts of Interest. Journal of Consumer Research, 37.
Church, B. K., & Kuang, X. (2009). Conflicts of Interest, Disclosure & (Costly) Sanctions: Experimental Evidence. Journal of Legal Studies, 38(2): 505-532.
Cunningham, G. M., & Harris, J. E. (2006). Enron & Arthur &erson: The Case of the Crooked E & the Fallen A. Global Perspectives on Accounting Education, 3, 27-48.
Dalley, P. J. (2007). The Use & Misuse of Disclosure as a Regulatory System, Florida State University Law Review, 34, 1089-1131.
Dana, J., & Loewenstein, G. (2003). A Social Science Perspective on Gifts to Physicians from Industry. The Journal of the American Medical Association 290: 252-255.
Dana, J., Weber, R. A., & Kuang, J. X. (2007). Exploiting moral wiggle room: experiments demonstrating an illusory preference for fairness. Economic Theory, 33(1): 67-80.
DeAngelis, C. D. (2000). Conflict of Interest & the Public Trust. 2000 America Medical Association. The Journal of the American Medical Association, 284(17), 2237-2238.
Dye, R. A. (2001). An Evaluation of ‘Essays on Disclosure’ & the Disclosure Literature in Accounting. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 32, 181-235.
Emanuel, E. J., & Thompson, D. F. (2008). The Concept of Conflicts of Interest, The Oxford Textbook of Clinical Research Ethics, 758, 764-765.
Farrington, D. P. (2001). Key Results from the First Forty Years of the Cambridge Study in Delinquent Development. In Thornberry, T. P., & Krohn, M. D. (Eds.) Taking Stock of Delinquency: An Overview of Findings from Contemporary Longitudinal Studies. New York: Kluwer/Plenum, in press.
Fung, A., Graham, M., & Weil, D. (2007). Full disclosure: The Perils and Promise of Transparency. Cambridge University Press.
Gilligan, C. (1982). In a different voice: Psychological theory and women's development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Gunderson, M. (1997). Eliminating Conflicts of Interest in Managed Care Organizations through Disclosure and Consent. Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics, 27, 5-15.
Güth, W., Steffen H., & Ockenfels, P. (1996). Two-Level Ultimatum Bargaining with Incomplete Information: An Experimental Study. The Economic Journal., 106(436), 593-604.
Hall, M. A., & Berenson, R. A. (1998). Ethical Practice in Managed Care: A Dose of Realism, Annels of Internal Medicine, 128(5), 395-402.
Harvey, A., Kirt, U., Denfield, G. H., & Montague, P. R. (2010). Monetary Favors and Their influence on Neural Responses and Revealed Preference, The Journal of Neuroscience. 30(28), 9597-9602.
Healy, P. M., & Palepu, K. G. (2001). Information Asymmetry, Corporate Disclosure, and the Capital Markets: A Review of the Empirical Disclosure Literature. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 31, 405-440.
Hoffman, M. L., & Saltzstein, H. D. (1967). Parent discipline and the child's moral development. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 5(1): 45-57.
Holstein, C. B. (1976). Irreversible, Stepwise Sequence in the Development of Moral Judgment: A Longitudinal Study of Males and Females, Child Development, 47(1): 51-61.
Juby, H., & Farrington, D. P. (2001). Disentangling the link between disrupted familes and delinquency, British Journal of Criminology, 41, 22-40.
Kang, B. H., Moon, J. Y., Chang, Y., Koo, Y. M., & Koh, Y. (2013). Current Levels of Conflict of Interest Disclosure in Medical Publications from Korea. Journal of Korean Medical Science, 28(7), 978-982.
Koch, C., & Schmidt, C. (2009). Disclosing Conflict of Interest: Does Experience and Reputation Matter? Accounting, Organizations and Society, 35(1): 95-107.
Kohlberg, L. (1981). Essays on moral development, Vol. 1: The philosophy of moral development. San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row. 김민남 역(1985). 도덕발달의 철학. 서울: 교육과학사.
Li, Y. (2010). The Case Analysis of the Scandal of Enron. International Journal of Business and Management, 5(10), 37-41.
Li, X., & Yang, H. (2015). Mandatory Financial Reporting and Voluntary Disclosure: The Effect of Mandatory IFRS Adoption on Management Forecasts(April 8, 2015). Available at SSRN:http://ssrn.com/abstract=2172014.
Loewenstein, G., Cain, D. M., & Sah, S. (2011). The Limits of Transparency: Pitfalls and Potential of Disclosing Conflicts of Interest. American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings, 101(3), 423-428.
Mazar, N., & Ariely, D. (2006). Dishonesty in Everyday Life and Its Policy Implications. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing, 25(1), 1-21.
Mazar, N., Amir, O., & Ariely, D. (2008). The Dishonesty of Honest People: A Theory of Self-concept Maintenance. Journal of Marketing Research, 45(6), 633-644.
Miller, P. B., & Weijer, H. (2009). Trust and Exploitation in Clinical Research, The Limits of Consent: A Socio-ethical Approach to Human Subject Research in Medicine. Corrigan, O., McMillan, J., Liddell, K., Richards, M., & Weijer, C. (Eds.), 25-37.
Miller, F. H. (1983). Secondary income from recommended treatment: should fiduciary principles constraints physician behavior? In: Gray B. H. ed. The New Health Care for Profit: Doctors and Hospitals in a Competitive Environment. Washington, D. C.: National Academy Press.
Monin, B., & Miller, D. T. (2001). Moral credentials and the expression of prejudice. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 81(1), 33-43.
Morash, M., & Rucker, L. (1989). An exploratory study of the connection of mother's age at childbearing to her children's delinquency in four data sets. Crime and Delinquency, 35, 45-93.
Moore, D. A., Tetlock. P. E, Tanlu, L., & Bazerman, M. H. (2012). Conflicts of Interest and the Case of Auditor Independence: Moral Seduction and Strategic Issue Cycling, HBS Working Parer #03-115. Rev.12/04.
OECD (2003). Managing Conflict of Interest in the Public Service. OECD.
Palmer, E. J., & Hollin, C. R. (1997). The influence of perceptions of own parenting on sociomoral reasoning, attributions for criminal behaviour, and self-reported delinquency. Personality and Individual Differences, 23(2): 193-197.
Piaget, J. (1932). The Moral Judgment of the Child, Londen: The Free Press.
Piff, P. K., Stancato, D. M., Cote, S., Mendoza-Denton, R., & Keltner, D. (2012). Higher social class predicts increased unethical behavior. PNAS, 109(11), 4086-4091.
Rest, J. R., Davison, M. L., & Robbins, S. (1978). Age Trends in Judging Moral Issues: A Review of Cross-Sectional, Longitudinal, and Sequential Studies of the Defining Issues Test. Child Development, 49(2): 263-279.
Rest, J. R. (1979). Development in Judging Moral Issures. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Rest, J. R. (1986). Moral development: Advances in research and theory. New York: Praeger; 문용린 외 공역(2008). 도덕발달 이론과 연구. 서울: 학지사.
Sah, S., Cain, D. M., & Loewenstein, G. (2013). The Burden of Disclosure: Increased Compliance With Distrusted Advice, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 104(2). 289-304.
Sah, S., & Loewenstein, G. (2014). Nothing to Declare: Mandatory and voluntary disclosure leads advisors to avoid conflicts of interest. Phychological Science, 25(2), 575-584.
Shu, L., Mazar, N., Gino, F., Bazerman, M. H., & Ariely, D. (2011). When to Sign on the Dotted Line? Signing First Makes Ethics Salient and Decreases Dishonest Self-Reports, Harvard Business school working paper.
Shweder, R. A., Mahapatra, M., & Miller, J. G. (1987). Culture and Moral Development, In: Kajan, J., & Lamb, S. ed. The Emergence of Morality in Young Children. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Thompson, D. F. (1993). Understanding Financial Conflicts of Interest. The New England Journal of Medicine, 329(8), 573-576.
Verrecchia, R. E. (2001). Essays on Disclosure. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 32, 97-180. and Economics, 32, 97-180.
Walker, L. J. (1984). Sex Differences in the Development of Moral Reasoning: A Critical Review. Child Development, 55(3): 677-691
Wazana, A. (2000). Physicians and the Pharmaceutical Industry: Is a Gift Ever Just a Gift? The Journal of the American Medical Association, 283(3), 373-380.
Weinfurt, K. P., Friedman, J. Y, Dinan, M. A, Allsbrook, J. S, Hall, M. A, Dhillon, J. K & Sugarman, J. (2006). Disclosing conflicts of interest in clinical research: views of institutional review boards, conflict of interest committees, and investigators. The Journal of Law, medicine & ethics, 34(3), 581-591.
West, T., Ravenscroft, S., & Shrader, C. (2004). Cheating and moral judgment in the college classroom: A natural experiment. Journal of Business Ethics, 54(2), 173-183.
- 다운로드 수
- 조회수
- 0KCI 피인용수
- 0WOS 피인용수