Legal-systemtic alternative to demestic Violence: therapeutic Jurisprudence

가정폭력은 아동기 경험에 의하여 폭력이 행동 레파토리로 학습된 남성이 사회적 존재로서의 자존감을 손상하는 경험을 반복적으로 하게 되는 경우에 나타나는 스트레스 반응이고, 결혼생활의 조화와 사회적 지지는 이 스트레스를 증폭하거나 완화시키는 완충역할을 한다는 견해가 설득력을 가진다. 가정폭력 사범의 교정을 위한 한국의 현행 제도는 교정과 치료가 교도행정기관에 의해 주도되므로 환자의 입장에서는 치료라기보다 대체형벌로 받아들일 가능성이 높아서 그 효과를 낙관하기 어렵고, 지역사회에서 낙인효과를 유발하여 재적응을 어렵게 만들며, 결과적으로 재범의 가능성을 높일 수 있다. 한국사회에서 가정폭력을 최소화하기 위한 법적 대처는 치료적 사법이념의 패러다임을 제도적 대처방안으로 섬세하게 고려할 필요가 있다. 치료적 사법이념의 핵심은 법원이 지역사회 및 다른 행정기관과 협력하여 범죄자의 치료와, 교정, 그리고 갱생을 위한 적극적이고 능동적인 역할을 해야 한다는 것이다.

keywords: domestic violence, social conficence, correctional administration, therapeutic jurisprudence, 가정폭력, 사회적 자존감, 교정, 치료적 사법이념, domestic violence, social conficence, correctional administration, therapeutic jurisprudence

Abstract

A review of literature revealed that damaged self-confidence of men as social agents may be the primary, if not proximal, cause of domestic violence. Accumulated damages in social confidence and self-assurance may be moderated by action repertoire acquired during childhood, and mediated by adulthood circumstances such as marital discords and the lack of social support to result in the typical cycle of violence and subsequent feeling of remorse. The present treatments for the domestically violent men in Korea seem to be ineffective to reduce the number of incidents in the society because the treatments are viewed as punishments by the men, damage their social confidence further by stigmatizing them in the community, and destroy their social resources and support systems. It was suggested in this paper to reduce the role of law enforcement and correctional administration to rehabilitate the currently violent men. At the same time, it was also suggested for the Korean court to implement the paradigm of Therapeutic Jurisprudence in handling domestic violence cases. It was argued that the court should take active roles as a healing and rehabilitating agent by cooperating with non-government community establishments such as hospitals, universities and self-help organizations. The reasons and implications of those suggestions were discussed in detail.

keywords: domestic violence, social conficence, correctional administration, therapeutic jurisprudence, 가정폭력, 사회적 자존감, 교정, 치료적 사법이념, domestic violence, social conficence, correctional administration, therapeutic jurisprudence

참고문헌

(2001) 가정폭력관련 법률의 효율성 제고방안,

(1999) 가정폭력방지법 시행 1주년과 여성인권. , 한국 여성의 전화 연합.

(1989) The effect of co-occurring disorders on criminal careers Interaction of antisocial personality International Journal of Law and Psychiatry,

(1997) An integration of feminist and family violence approaches Journal of Marriage and the Family, Journal of Marriage and the Family,

(1991) The influence of testosterone on human aggression,

(2002) Is domestic violence learned? The contribution of five forms of child maltreatment to men's violence and adjustment ,

(1982) Journal of Family Issues,

(1989) Seroternogic studies in patients with affective and personality disorders Archives of General Psychiatry,

(1986) The relationship of problem drinking to individual offending sequences, National Academy Press

10.

(1987) Saliva testosterone and criminal violence in young adult prison inmates,

11.

(1990) and antisocial behavior in a sample of 4,

12.

(2000) Disciplining children: Characteristics associated with the use of corporal punishment., Child Abuse & Neglect

13.

(1986) The application of stress theory to the study of family violence Journal of Family Violence, Principles

14.

(1987) Perpetrators of domestic violence An overview of counseling the court-mandated client Domestic Violence on Trial Psychological and Legal Dimensions of Family Violence,

15.

(1989) Child abuse and violence in single parent families:Parent absence and economic deprivation,

16.

(1993a) Current Controversies on Family Violence,

17.

(1993b) Alcohol and other drugs are associated with violence Current Controversies on Family Violence,

18.

(1989) Characteristics of treatment completers and dropouts,

19.

(1986) An analysis of risk markers in husband to wife violence The current state of knowledge,

20.

(1989) Relationship of testosterone to men's family functioning at mid-life,

21.

(1984) The intergenerational transmission of marital aggression,

22.

(1986) Continuity of marital behavior in remarriage The case of spouse abuse Journal of Marriage and the Family,

23.

(1987) theory of wife beating,

24.

(1986) Violence in the context of dating and sex Journal of Family Issues,

25.

(1992) and ethanol in males arrested for spouse abuse,

26.

(1981) Courtship violence among college students,

27.

(2002) Collateral damage: An analysis of the achievement and unintended consequences of batterer intervention programs and discourse,

28.

(1992) The epidemiology of alcohol- related interpersonal violence,

29.

(1995) Toward a biopsychological model of domestic violence,

30.

(1981) The Biology of Aggression,

31.

(1991) A review of the literature Journal of Interpersonal Violence,

32.

(1993) and levels of violence Current Controversies on Family Violence,

33.

(1976) Alcohol and crimes of violence The Biology of Alcoholism Social Aspects of Alcoholism, Plenum

34.

(1978) Clinical Aspects of the Rapist, Grune & Stratton

35.

(1988) Personality and biographical data that characterize men who abuse their wives Journal of Clinical Psychology,

36.

(1988) Socialization and stress explanations for spouse abuse,

37.

(1996) Therapeutic Jurisprudence:Five Dilemmas to Ponder, Academic Press

38.

(1980) Social stress and marital violence in a national sample of American families,

39.

(1980) Violence in the American Family, Basic Books

40.

(1987) Handbook of Marriage and the Family, Plenum

41.

(1995) A review of quantitative research on men who batter ,

42.

(1989) Biosocial models of adolescent behavior problems University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Unpublished manuscript

43.

(1993) Journal of Studies on Alcohol,

44.

(1988) Effects of alcohol on aggressive behavior in squirrel monkeys Influence of testosterone and social context,

45.

(1985) Social status as determinant of alcohol effects on aggressive behavior in squirrel monkeys,

46.

(1993) Current Controversies on Family Violence,

바로가기메뉴

논문 상세

Vol.10 No.특집

가정폭력에 대한 법제도적 대안: 치료적 사법이념의 관점

Legal-systemtic alternative to demestic Violence: therapeutic Jurisprudence

초록

Abstract

참고문헌

한국심리학회지 : 문화 및 사회문제